Fennell'S 'Wuthering Heights' Offers A Provocative Yet Shallow Spin On Brontë'S Classic

A New Vision of Heathcliff and Cathy

Emerald Fennell's daring rendition of 'Wuthering Heights' shakes things up with its bold creative choices, but it might leave purists wanting more. Jacob Elordi steps into the role of Heathcliff with a mix of brooding intensity and a surprising modern sensitivity toward consent. Yet, while he's convincing in his passion, the raw fury that made Heathcliff an unforgettable character seems dialed down. This version sees him more as a protector of Cathy than her tormentor.

Margot Robbie's portrayal of Cathy brings a gothic twist reminiscent of Scarlett O’Hara – she's selfish, vain, and intriguingly unpredictable. Robbie shines in moments of unexpected vulnerability, hinting at emotions that Cathy herself can't fully grasp. "It's fascinating to watch her battle feelings she can't control," notes one critic.

“It's fascinating to watch her battle feelings she can't control,” notes one critic.

A Visual Feast with Mixed Results

The film's visuals play a significant role, with costume designer Jacqueline Durran drawing from various influences, including 1950s melodramas. The result is a conscious artificiality that may please the eye but sometimes detracts from the narrative. From Catherine's skin-colored bedroom decor to her outlandish wedding attire, the set and costume choices often elicit more questions than they answer.

Fennell aims to provoke and engage, much like she did with 'Promising Young Woman.' Yet, in 'Wuthering Heights,' this provocation sometimes skews towards distraction rather than depth. "It’s as if the audience is supposed to question why more than what," commented a viewer.

“It’s as if the audience is supposed to question why more than what,” commented a viewer.

A Polarizing Take on a Classic

Known for pushing boundaries, Fennell explores the extremes of human nature and societal norms. While her approach can be exhilarating and even scandalous, it often balances on the edge of entertainment and discomfort. Fans of her previous work might find something to enjoy, but others might view this as a misstep in her otherwise compelling repertoire.

While the reinterpretation of 'Wuthering Heights' may leave some viewers scratching their heads, it undoubtedly sparks conversation. As Fennell continues to navigate between artful and outrageous, audiences are left to decide whether they are charmed or challenged by her vision.