Top 10 Netflix Horror Movies To Scream About This September

Get Ready for Chills with Netflix's Top Horror Picks

As the temperature drops, there's no better time to cozy up and dive into a spine-tingling horror movie marathon. If you're overwhelmed by the sheer number of options on Netflix, don't worry – we've got you covered. We've sifted through Rotten Tomatoes scores to bring you the top ten horror films streaming in September 2025. So grab your popcorn and prepare for a frightful night in.

The Countdown Begins

#10: Creep (2014)

Kick off your horror marathon with "Creep," where Mark Duplass shines as Josef, a bizarre character who hires a videographer (Patrick Brice) for a seemingly simple task. But as the day unfolds, it becomes clear that Josef's intentions are far from ordinary, leaving viewers on edge.

#9: Gerald’s Game (2017)

This thriller, adapted from Stephen King's novel, portrays a psychological battle as Jesse (Carla Gugino) fights for survival after a romantic retreat turns deadly. Handcuffed to a bed in a remote house, she must confront the shadows of her past after her husband, Gerald (Bruce Greenwood), suddenly dies.

“Stephen King's works continue to thrill and terrify – ‘Gerald's Game’ is no exception," noted a horror film enthusiast.

#8: 1922 (2017)

Also drawn from King’s imagination, "1922" offers a chilling tale of greed and guilt. Wilfred James (Thomas Jane) coerces his son into committing a heinous crime to secure a piece of land, only to find that the consequences are far more haunting than he anticipated.

More Spooks Await

#7: Cam (2018)

"Cam" presents a modern horror story as Alice Ackerman (Madeline Brewer), a camgirl, faces a terrifying identity crisis when her online persona is taken over by a mysterious doppelganger.

#6: Talk to Me (2022)

This fresh addition to the genre invites you to explore the supernatural as a group of teens discover that a severed hand allows them to communicate with spirits. The chilling consequences will keep you hooked.

#5: The Old Ways (2020)

Journalist Cristina (Brigitte Kali Canales) returns to her roots for a story on witchcraft, only to find herself accused of possession. As she faces local beliefs and ancient rituals, the line between reality and folklore blurs.

#4: Jaws (1975)

Steven Spielberg’s classic, "Jaws," remains a must-watch with its tale of a menacing great white shark terrorizing a New England town. The movie's impact on the horror genre is undeniable, leaving a legacy of shark-induced fears.

Top Three Terror-Inducing Titles

#3: Under the Shadow (2016)

Set against the backdrop of 1980s Tehran, "Under the Shadow" follows Shideh (Narges Rashidi) and her daughter as they are tormented by mysterious forces. The film expertly combines historical context with supernatural horror.

#2: Creep 2 (2017)

The sequel to "Creep" intensifies the scare factor as Josef reveals his dark side to YouTuber Sara (Desiree Akhavan). He invites her to film him for 24 hours, promising safety – but only time will tell if he'll keep his word.

#1: His House (2020)

Topping the list is "His House," a haunting story of South Sudanese refugees Bol (Sope Dirisu) and Rial (Wunmi Mosaku) who face supernatural trials in their new UK home. It's a deeply unsettling look at displacement and the horror of the unknown.