Courtney Clenney'S Legal Team Gears Up For Trial With New Evidence In Murder Case

  • By Imani
  • June 3, 2026, 9 a.m.

Defense Team Examines Crucial Evidence

In the high-profile case of OnlyFans model Courtney Clenney, her defense team has recently had the opportunity to scrutinize key evidence as they prepare for her trial. Arrested in August 2022, Clenney is charged with second-degree murder in the stabbing death of her boyfriend, Christian “Toby” Obumseli. The incident occurred in their shared Miami apartment on April 3, 2022, when Obumseli tragically succumbed to a three-inch-deep stab wound to the chest.

Clenney maintains that she acted in self-defense, a claim her attorneys are gearing up to support. During a pretrial hearing on June 1, they confirmed examining the knives involved in the incident. They're also ramping up for additional legal maneuvers, with more than eight depositions lined up as part of their pretrial strategy.

OnlyFans Model Courtney Clenney

OnlyFans Model Courtney Clenney

Progress Amid Preparations and Setbacks

Despite facing obstacles earlier this year, Clenney's legal team now reports progress. They had previously expressed frustrations during an April hearing over the failure of subpoenaed witnesses to appear for depositions. However, by June 1, they were back on track, aligning efforts ahead of the trial, which is set to commence this summer, though a specific date hasn't been announced yet.

Prosecutors are also moving forward, with plans for their expert to assess Clenney on June 9. Ensuring this evaluation doesn't hinder the timeline, they assured the court that trial preparations remain on schedule.

“If we’re in the same position next time we come back and these witnesses are just not appearing, I mean, there’s going to come a time when it’s fish or cut bait, right?” Judge Andrea Wolfson stated during the hearing.
Courtney Clenney Murder Trial

Courtney Clenney Murder Trial

Background and Trial Delays

Before her arrest, Clenney was a notable figure on OnlyFans and had amassed a substantial following on social media. At the time of her arrest, she was in Hawaii, where her attorney stated she was undergoing rehabilitation for substance abuse and PTSD.

The trial's original start date was slated for late April, but it faced a delay due to both parties requesting more time. This was largely due to scheduling issues with depositions, which prosecutors intended to use to establish a pattern of behavior. The court has been firm that further delays will not be entertained.

Imani
Author: Imani
Imani

Imani

Imani follows the money: payouts, contracts, lawsuits, and platform enforcement. With a background in entertainment PR and paralegal work, she breaks complex stories into plain-English playbooks for creators. Her series Follow the Money connects drama to data - who benefits, who pays, and what to do next. Calm, sourced, and courtroom-ready; DTLA is her second office.